Fallen, but not Forgotten: Pvt. James Chaney, Co. I, 1st USCI

ECW is pleased to welcome back Tim Talbott, director of education and interpretation at Pamplin Historical Park

Historians estimate that perhaps as many as twenty percent of Civil War soldiers enlisted under the age of 18. While enlisting officials were not supposed to accept anyone under army regulation age, in effort to fill companies and regiments, they sometimes made exceptions to the rule. Many of these youths served in support roles: musicians, hospital assistants, and couriers, among other duties, yet thousands of youngsters saw combat as arms bearing soldiers, too.

One underage soldier, James Chaney, enlisted in Co. I, 1st United States Colored Infantry, at only 16 years of age. Being so young, Chaney did not have much opportunity to leave a significant amount of documentation that recorded his brief life.

Regiment identified as 1st USCT (LOC)

Cheney, apparently born free around 1847, in Baltimore, Maryland, appears in the 1850 federal census in that city’s 18th Ward as a four year old. Residing in the household of his mother, Elizabeth “Eliza” Chaney (25 years of age), and his brothers, Isaac (6), Lewis (2), and George (3 months), were also Arlenthia Cheney (18), who was perhaps Eliza’s sister; Benjamin Thomas (18) and John W. Thomas (12). Everyone is described as “mulatto,” and only Benjamin Thomas has an occupation, “laborer,” listed. Having so many youthful individuals in the household, with so little work experience, and thus few chances to build earning power, probably meant times were financially tight for the Chaneys and Thomases.

A decade later, perhaps due to family economic needs, James, Isaac, and Lewis appear residing in a 16th Ward Baltimore hotel owned by William Dorbacker. The three Chaney boys, along with John and William Nelson, all listed as “black,” and noted as “servants,” are the only African Americans residing at the hotel. Full-service hotels of the period readily employed both free and enslaved men, women, and children to clean rooms, do laundry, serve as bell hops and barbers, cook meals, and wait on tables. Free blacks sometimes received wages, tips, and room and board as their compensation.

Washington, D.C.’s, National Hotel (LOC)

It was likely that the experience James Chaney gained while working in Dorbacker’s hotel helped bring him to Washington, D.C., sometime between the summer of 1860 and his enlistment in the Union army in the summer of 1863. Records show that James worked as a waiter at Banks’s Restaurant and the National Hotel in Washington City before joining up. These records also state that James gave the “greater part of his wages to his mother” so she could buy food, clothes, and pay her rent. Apparently Elizabeth Chaney suffered from bad health that left her unable to work consistently and caused her “spasms . . . so severe as to render her . . . unable for five or six days to perform labor or any sort.” Thus, Elizabeth Chaney “depended upon him for the greater part of her support.” James Cheney was a model son.

One wonders what James Chaney’s primary motivation was to enlist on June 28, 1863. Did he tire of his monotonous waiter duties and desire to experience the supposed adventure that came with a soldier’s life? Did he think he could earn more money in the army to help support his mother? Was he more mature in his worldviews than we typically credit to 16-year olds and thus wish to see slavery eradicated and to prove that men of color could be just as courageous and worthy of citizenship as white men? Obviously, being officially underage, Chaney did not have to enlist. But he did!

Mason’s Island during the Civil War (LOC)

Enlisting the 1st USCI’s Company I at age 16, with the stated occupation of waiter, Cheney measured five feet five and a half inches tall, with a complexion described as “yellow.” Signing up on June 28, 1863, on Mason’s Island (now Theodore Roosevelt Island) in the Potomac River, Chaney’s enlistment officer was Col. William Birney, son of noted abolitionist and former Liberty Party presidential candidate James G. Birney. Col. Birney was older brother of Maj. Gen. David Bell Birney, who was then leading a division in the Army of the Potomac. Experienced officer Col. John Holman received the assignment to initially command the 1st USCI.

After serving in southeastern Virginia and northeastern North Carolina during the fall and winter of 1863-64, the 1st USCI transferred to the division of Brig. Gen. Edward Hinks in the XVIII Corps of the newly created Army of the James. It appears that James Chaney received a brief promotion to corporal around September or October 1863, but by November 4 he was reduced to the ranks for an unspecified reason. Posted at various occupied points along the James River during the spring of 1864, the 1st USCI received its first taste of combat at Wilson’s Warf (Fort Pocahontas) on May 24, 1864, where they battled Maj. Gen. Fitzhugh Lee’s Confederate cavalry, eventually driving off the rebel attackers.

The 1st USCI, now consolidated with the rest of Hinks’s Division, also battled at both Baylor’s Farm and assaulted the Dimmock Line at Petersburg on June 15, 1864, where they fought especially well. Pvt. Chaney appears to have survived these actions unscathed and in good health. Stationed part of the time in the Petersburg trenches and again at points along the James River, Chaney’s regiment gathered with the rest of the division, now under the command of Brig. Gen. Charles J. Paine, at Deep Bottom for a late September assault at New Market Heights.

Commanding the First Brigade of the Third Division, XVIII Corps, was Col. John Holman, who previously led the 1st USCI. His brigade included the 1st, 22nd, and 37th USCI regiments. However, in July, Chaney received orders to serve on detached duty with the Third Division, XVIII Corps sharpshooter company. Chaney’s superiors must have noticed his excellent marksmanship skills to receive this special assignment.

Service in the division sharpshooters meant Chaney would be one of the first to contact the enemy, skirmishing out ahead of the primary assaulting brigades. It is likely that Chaney received the wound that resulted in his death on the New Market Heights battlefield early in the fight. He probably was not able to witness the amazing bravery displayed by his Third Division comrades as they struggled against the determined Confederate Texas Brigade defenders for control of the New Market Road that fateful September 29, 1864, day.

As was common practice, Pvt. Chaney probably received a soldier’s grave in the very battlefield he fought over. After the war most of the United States Colored Troops soldiers killed in action at New Market Heights, who could be located, were reinterred at Fort Harrison National Cemetery or City Point National Cemetery. Today, Pvt. Chaney may fill an unknown soldier’s grave at one of these locations, or his remains may still rest on the battlefield. We will probably never know for sure. However, we honor this youthful soldier’s service, remember his sacrifice that helped abolish the scourge of slavery and maintained the United States of America. A life lost too early on its earthly journey will not be forgotten, but instead lives on with this humble expression of respect.


Tim Talbott is the Director of Education, Interpretation, Visitor Services, and Collections at Pamplin Historical Park and the National Museum of the Civil War Soldier in Petersburg, Virginia. He is also the founding member and President of the Battle of New Market Heights Memorial and Education Association. Tim maintains the “Random Thoughts on History” blog and has published articles in both book and scholarly journal format. His current project is researching soldiers captured during the Petersburg Campaign.



1850 United States Census, accessed via Ancestry.com

1860 United States Census, accessed via Ancestry.com

Civil War “Widows” Pensions, accessed via Fold3.com

Complied Military Service Record for Pvt. James Chaney (1st USCI), accessed via Fold3.com

Dobak, William A. Freedom by the Sword: The U.S. Colored Troops, 1862-1867. Skyhorse Publishing, 2013.


The mission of the Battle of New Market Heights Memorial and Education Association is to commemorate and educate. We seek to erect a monument at the site of the Battle of New Market Heights honoring the United States Colored Troops who served in the Third Division of the XVIII Corps (Army of the James). Among these men were fourteen African American soldiers and two white officers who received the Medal of Honor for acts of heroism on September 29, 1864. We also seek to educate the public about this significant military victory by the United States Colored Troops. More information is available at https://battleofnewmarketheights.org. As part of a collaboration between ECW and BNMHMEA, this piece is cross-posted at their website. 

3 Responses to Fallen, but not Forgotten: Pvt. James Chaney, Co. I, 1st USCI

  1. “A life lost too early on its earthly journey will not be forgotten, but instead lives on with this humble expression of respect.” Perhaps this should be ECW’s motto.

Please leave a comment and join the discussion!