Question of the Week: 4/11-4/17/22

In your opinion, what should be the most famous march of the Civil War?

(Referring to actual military movement from Point A to Point B, not military marching music!)

This entry was posted in Question of the Week and tagged , . Bookmark the permalink.

19 Responses to Question of the Week: 4/11-4/17/22

  1. nygiant1952 says:

    The Mud March

  2. Larry De Maar says:

    Sherman’s March to the Sea

  3. Ed Cunningham says:

    The 6th Corps march to Gettysburg July 1-2.

  4. mark harnitchek says:

    Grant’s march around Lee’s right flank from Cold Harbor to Petersburg, to include the construction of a large pontoon bridge across the James River.

  5. Ted Romans says:

    From the Confederate point of view, it may have not been the longest, but it could be seen as one of the most important marches. The forced March of A.P. Hill’s Light Division on September 17th from Harper’s Ferry to Sharpsburg. You could make the case that it literally saved Lee’s Army from destruction.

  6. Daniel Nettesheim says:

    Herron’s 3 day forced march of over 100 miles under severe winter conditions to reinforce Blunt & resulted in the strategic victory at the battle of Prairie Grove

  7. W. Charles Young says:

    Jackson’s flank march around Pope to Manassas and, after yesterday’s post, Morgan’s march out of the Cumberland Gap to the Ohio River.

  8. Bryan Wiedeman 2-75thRGR says:

    Pull out a map put your finger on Cairo Illinois meander across Tennessee and end up in Vicksburg then trace to Chattanooga to Atlanta. Now wait till dead-of winter back at Atlanta head to Savanna then trace up through frozen swamps and overflowing rivers and end up at Goldsboro NC/ Virginia border…and be ready with rifle and cannon to tear into the Army of Northern Virginia.

  9. Chris Mackowski says:

    I’m a big fan of Jackson’s flank march at Chancellorsville, but I see a lot of great suggestions here. It’s hard to argue with Sherman’s March to the Sea since it, moreso than any other mentioned, has earned capitalization over the years! 😉

  10. Douglas Pauly says:

    Shilo has been a popular subject on these boards this month, so I’m going to go with Buell’s march there. The claims of what that accomplished are all over the spectrum, from Grant’s army being saved from a desperate situation to Grant’s ‘last line’ being more than adequately defended and thus Buell’s contribution was not that important. Both generals would feud about all of that. BUT, Buell’s arrival did serve as a morale booster to the Union forces, and Grant then had the troop numbers to go on the offensive the next day.

    I’ll give an “honorable mention” to Jubal Early’s July 1864 march into Maryland and his hazarding of Washington, DC,, and Lew Wallace’s sortie out of Baltimore to intercept him.

  11. Lyle Smith says:

    It’s 2022 folks, all the marches were wonderful.

  12. Tony Robertson says:

    I second Daniel Nettesheim above, on Herron’s to Prairie Grove. 100 plus miles, three days, December, the Ozarks. And much less heralded than others mentioned.

  13. Charlie Downs says:

    A P Hill’s march from Harper’s Ferry to Antietam. It saved the day for Lee.

  14. Douglas Pauly says:

    I’m surprised this wasn’t mentioned, seeing how it so recently presented on here!

    https://emergingcivilwar.com/2022/04/10/morgans-magnificent-march-from-cumberland-gap/

  15. Pingback: Week In Review: April 11-17, 2022 | Emerging Civil War

Please leave a comment and join the discussion!