Question of the Week: What if Nathaniel Banks was Lincoln’s VP?
Hypothetical thinking time: Abraham Lincoln picks Nathaniel Banks as his running mate in the 1864 election. How might that impact future events?
Hypothetical thinking time: Abraham Lincoln picks Nathaniel Banks as his running mate in the 1864 election. How might that impact future events?
In order to answer this hypothetical question, is it assumed President Abraham Lincoln would still be assassinated at Ford’s theater and Nathaniel P. Banks would be the US President during Reconstruction?
All I know about Banks is that he was a prewar speaker of the house and was a generally unsuccessful Union general. I would also bet good money that he would have been a far better president than Andrew Johnson.
During his time administrating Louisiana, Banks got one of the first cracks at Reconstruction policy. While there, he did adopt some policies to support the newly freed African Americans, but also believed in the necessity of incorporating white Southerners (even formerly rebellious ones) into his policies for them to succeed. This almost necessarily, of course, impeded on any effort to secure the rights and freedom of the formerly enslaved. During his service as a Reconstruction-era representative, meanwhile, he was noted a generally moderate Republican, although one who was willing to adopt the Radical party line when necessary. All of this to say, Banks was a wily political chameleon and frequently a deft operator. Assuming Lincoln is still assassinated and Banks becomes president, he certainly handles Reconstruction better than Johnson, although friction still likely arises between himself and the Radicals in Congress. He likely is more open and supportive of the rights of the newly freed, but his cooperation with the formerly rebellious is certain to drive a wedge between him and Congress. In the end, Reconstruction’s efforts to empower African Americans almost certainly still fail, but given the realities of the time, that is hardly avoidable. Even Lincoln himself would have struggled to make it succeed.
Had Nathaniel Banks succeeded Lincoln in 1865 rather than Andrew Johnson, the bitter constitutional warfare of “Congressional Reconstruction” likely never occurs. As a former Republican Speaker and moderate pragmatist, Banks would have collaborated with Capitol Hill to sign the Civil Rights Act and the Freedmen’s Bureau bills, bypassing the veto battles, military occupation, and impeachment drama that defined Johnson’s tenure.
Yet this harmonious executive-legislative compromise almost certainly would have yielded a far more conservative settlement—reintegrating the Southern states under transitional, contract-labor systems while deferring genuine Black political equality for generations. Ironically, the nation was arguably better served by Johnson’s intransigent racism, which backfired so spectacularly that it unified Northern moderates behind the Radicals.
By forcing Congress to bypass the White House, Johnson’s obstruction catalyzed the transformative breakthroughs of the Fourteenth and Fifteenth Amendments, guaranteeing birthright citizenship, equal protection under the law, and universal male suffrage as permanent constitutional law.
Banks was a far more savy political animal than Johnson, probably able to outmaneuver both the ultras in his own party, and the unreconstructed rebebels in the other. A broader based polity might have been able to defang the growth of Jim Crow, especially as the disappearnce of the Radical Republicns in the late 1870s inadvertently gave over the playing field to a race based, populist southern white populism.
The Slaughterhouse cases of 1873 and the 5 Civil Rights cases of 1883 gutted the Federal Government’s power to protect newly freed African Americans and feared the path for the Jim Crow era.
This is very interesting question, but I’ll just say this question was never even a possibility, remote at best, because the Republican delegates in 1864 wanted a “War Democrat” to be the Vice-President on the ticket. Banks was a Republican. This is also a major reason why Hannibal Hamlin was not chosen to run as Vice-President again. Furthermore Banks had just failed in the Red River campaign and was removed from command on Grant’s recommendation weeks before the 1864 Republican convention.
Men who were looked at besides Andrew Johnson, were the likes of John A. Dix, Daniel S. Dickinson, and Joseph Holt. Lincoln apparently had no say in the choice and told people he wanted no say in it.
Great “what if” question. Very enlightening answers!
I don’t think Banks’s war record would have been an asset to the ticket. He was definitely a savvy politician, so I think he would have been better than Johnson, but that’s a low bar, but his mediocrity as a general would have been a major weakness as he tried to wrangle the competing factions because no one would have seen him as a strong figure. He had some relationships to draw on, yes, but he did not have an especially long or even impactful tenure in office at the national level, so he would not have had a lot of political capital to draw on by 1865.
Imagine if he’d been on the ticket in 1861? (Highly unlikely…but let’s say he somehow emerged as an alternative consensus candidate to Hamlin.) He was the fourth-highest-ranking general in the Union army by 1862. Had he NOT been in the Valley, who would have been there? How would that have impacted the Valley campaign? In and of itself, the Valley Campaign wasn’t necessarily vital but it DID have an impact on the availability of Federal reinforcements for McClellan outside of Richmond, and that WAS a big deal.
A related question. Forget the theoretical Banks. What if Maj. Gen. William Rosecrans, a War Democrat, had been placed on the 1864 ticket? There is some evidence that Lincoln’s allies, especially Rosecrans’ former chief-of-staff, James Garfield, actually sounded out Rosecrans for the vice presidency. Supposedly Edwin Stanton intercepted Rosecrans’ positive telegraphic reply, scuttling the effort.
I’ve read that too, but it seems to have happened outside of the actual convention. Benjamin Butler in his memoirs said he was offered the position directly by Lincoln himself, but that appears to be balderdash.
Rosecrans would have been interesting, as he was a practicing Catholic and had Andrew Johnson’s support postbellum.
If Banks was on the Republican ticket, Lincoln would never have won the presidency. Banks was an anti-immigrant Know Nothing and his candidacy would have cancelled out the German vote in the 1860 election.
I don’t know if Banks would have cost Lincoln the election (he wouldn’t have helped much), but it is true, like Thaddeus Stevens, Banks had been a Know-Nothing and had a public record of bigotry towards immigrants.
Patrick, I’m actually having challenging time finding anti-immigrant comments or positions from Banks, other than being a Know-Nothing. Sources suggest Banks wasn’t that anti-immigrant and focused on the Massachusetts Know-Nothing anti-slavery position. Perhaps he just let others speak for himself and he wisely said little. Interesting.
What do you know?