Saving History Saturday: Relocating A Statue

The following original press release was dated February 6, 2021, from Dalton, Georgia. It offers details about a solution found for moving and preserving a Civil War statue in a way agreeable to many in that local community.

On July 8, 2020, following 30 days of several marches and demonstrations, a town hall meeting in which a number of persons spoke to the Council of Dalton about the removal of the Joseph E. Johnston Statue from public property, a Facebook petition to move to statue and another Facebook petition to not move the statue, the City of Dalton notified the local Chapter of the United Daughters of the Confederacy (hereinafter “UDC”) that the UDC needed to make arrangements to move the statue as any permissive easement to allow its continued placement on the public right of way of the intersection of Crawford and Hamilton Streets were no longer permitted.  The City of Dalton gave the UDC a reasonable time period within which to arrange to move the statue.

The UDC expressed last summer that it was ready and willing to move the statue provided that a suitable location could be found AND provided that funds sufficient to safely handle the move could be secured as the UDC did not have any money to be able to do so.  The City of Dalton expressed that it would not pay for any move or use any tax dollars.  Members of the community at large including some of the original marchers volunteered to raise funds to pay for the move.

The Community Foundation of Northwest Georgia which took no position on the subject of whether to move the statue or not to move it, offered to serve as a conduit, or bank, to facilitate the anonymous donations required for the move.

Several possible locations were identified as potential places for the relocation of the statue:

  1. Whitfield County graciously offered to permit the statue to be relocated to the new Rocky Face Ridge Park to be opened soon in Crow Valley. This was deemed to not be a suitable location for several reasons:
    1. The issue of maintaining the statue on public (i.e. government) lands still remained;
    2. The statue would move several miles out of town and outside of the downtown Dalton district where it was originally intended to be placed; and
    3. The new park, while it will have some civil war features and assets, will be a multi-use park including recreation, mountain biking, hiking, conservation and environmental uses in addition to historic uses.
  1. The Confederate Cemetery at West Hill Cemetery. This was ruled out quickly for several reasons:
    1. There is insufficient room to place the statue without disrupting some graves or other monuments;
    2. That is a place of rest for those buried there and should be kept as such for them. There are 421 Confederate and 4 Federal soldiers buried there;
    3. There is a relationship between the cemetery and the City of Dalton which could arguably be considered public use under the meaning of applicable laws; and
    4. To the extent that any State or other laws applied, this statue was not originally designed to be placed in a cemetery or museum and thus should not be placed in one.
  2. The Huff House owned by the Whitfield-Murray Historical Society, Inc. (hereinafter “Historical Society”)

This became the logical and best solution in which the UDC found themselves and the Board of Trustees of the Historical Society graciously voted and agreed to host the statue and give a lease to the UDC to relocate the statue there under certain conditions which had to be met:

  • First, the Historical Society would not claim or acquire any ownership to or responsibility for maintenance of the statue, same continuing to be the responsibility of the UDC which has maintained the statue for over 100 years;
  • The Historical Society would not pay for the move or for the installment of a new pad in which to place the statue;
  • A fence surrounding the statue and part of the back yard of the Huff House site would need to be included in the project;
  • 24/7 lighting would need to be installed on the statue;
  • Security cameras covering the statue would need to be acquired and installed.
  • The Historical Society would not insure the statue, same being the responsibility of the UDC.

The UDC was given an initial estimated budget based upon the pledged donations of $20,000 for the entirety of the project. Bids as high as $55,000 and $35,000 solely for the movement of the statue exclusive of all of the other costs outlined above came in from non-local companies.  After several months of lining up bids and proposals, and using only local companies and persons, bids and estimates have come in at between $30,000-35,000 for ALL of the work identified in the six parts to paragraph 3 above.

Donors willing to support this project next worked on raising the additional funding which was completed early this year.

The City of Dalton has provided the past several months to allow time for this project and all of the people involved to work together, and the City has assisted with the logistical support to ensure the safe relocation of the statue, but no tax dollars have to our knowledge been spent or allocated by the City.

One point that needs to be made very clear to the Citizens of Dalton and Whitfield County: No one involved in this process has intimated or attempted to tear down or destroy the statue or the history of it.  That group simply wanted it moved from a public property and were willing to pay for its relocation.

The historic Huff House was in fact the headquarters of General Joseph E. Johnston during the Confederate Army of Tennessee’s winter encampment in Dalton for about six months from December 1863 to May 1864.  It is a logical place for the statue where the history of the man, the statue and the house may all be interpreted and visited.

The location of the placement of the statue is significant and was chosen for several reasons.  It will be placed on Hawthorne Street facing north which is symbolic of him facing north toward his former enemy.  By placing the statue in this location, the Huff House may be viewed and enjoyed from the Selvidge Street, or west side, without the statue being in the viewshed of the house such that the house may be studied and enjoyed separately from the statue.  Conversely, the statue may also be viewed, studied and enjoyed separately from the house and opportunities for photos of either historic site can be had separately.  It allows each of the two sites to continue to have their own separate identities and prominence, while still being available to view and enjoy in one location. Additionally, the new location will better insure its safekeeping with additional security measures of a fence, lighting, and security cameras.

Thus, on the morning of February 6, 2021, the process of moving the statue was completed. This date and time was chosen out of consideration for the many businesses, restaurants, churches and shopkeepers downtown so as not disrupt their business and to cause as little disruption as possible. For this reason, a week-day or Sunday was not chosen.

We provide this press release so that everyone can see both the circumstances and the process for how this project came together.  In many communities across our country, unfortunately, similar circumstances have led to violence, bloodshed, vandalism and destruction of people, property, businesses, and statues.  In Dalton, however, the various parties have worked together to find and to carry out a good solution. We hope that the new location of the statue will lead to greater interest to and support of the Huff House and our new partners in the Whitfield-Murray Historical Society, Inc. as they strive to preserve all of our area’s rich history.

******
Submitted on behalf of my client for immediate release.

Robert D. Jenkins, Sr.
Attorney,
Dalton, GA

This entry was posted in Monuments, Preservation and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

11 Responses to Saving History Saturday: Relocating A Statue

  1. meven89143 says:

    That is the way to “remove” or move a statue. Well done

  2. William T. Anderson says:

    Excellent letter and process on a controversial subject.

  3. Thanks for your good work as well!

  4. Rod says:

    There is only one major issue everyone overlooks. This isn’t “saving history.” The historical intent of those who placed the statue there is being defied. History is therefore being altered and for what? So that those committed to a neo-Marxist “cancel culture” will get there way. It is wrong as it prompted an unfunded mandate on the UDC. It is especially wrong because the ultimate motive is a narrative of the war based more on political agenda than historical evidence. That it was done in a less controversial and more conciliatory manner does not change the wrong. And the further we go down this road of viewing history through a lens focused on race and victimization, the more we will see history being lost to those who weaponize a false historical narrative in order to vilify all American ideals.

  5. Tony Robertson says:

    To be more historically accurate, they should just keep backing the statue up, toward Atlanta.

  6. Mike Maxwell says:

    “Arguably considered public use…” [Item 2c]. Anyone visiting a Confederate cemetery is doing so intentionally. And anyone visiting a National Military Park, funded by the taxpayer, is likely to encounter reminders of the defeated side, in the form of statues, monuments, displays in the Visitor Center… To “rule out quickly” the appropriate, established use of public land, to include re-homing of orphaned statues is illogical and worse, bloody-minded.

  7. Judy Scarlata says:

    I kind of agree with Rod in a way. I’m a “ Yankee, “ I guess, as I live in upstate New York, although my people were Irish and hadn’t been here that long. ( My great-grandfather was born durning the Civil War in Albany, NY). But I am also a student of preserving and understanding history. As I read the story about Joe Johnston’s statue getting “kicked” out of a “right of way?”in Dalton and then people used FACEBOOK petitions? Why was Facebook (censorship) used?…. couldn’t they have gone door to door? 30 days of demonstrating by who? Antifa? Black Lives Matter? Both are communist fronts! The people in Dalton were duped, I think. But then we’re up here dealing with Cuomo! I find it very sad that our good American people are bowing to these “beings” that are shoving a way of life down are throats all in the name of getting rid of systemic racism. Kind of like Sherman burning down the South to get rid of the rebels.

  8. Dan Hurley says:

    Excellent peaceful process to move a statue appropriately. Although space may have been an issue, the cemetery seemed a good place with 400 Confederates. Well done.

  9. Katy Berman says:

    Glad to hear it was resolved respectfully.

Please leave a comment and join the discussion!