Question of the Week #5

“Which Valley Campaign had a larger impact on the war in the east, the 1862 Valley Campaign or the 1864 Valley Campaign?”

The Virginia Military Institute in ruins.

This entry was posted in Battles, Campaigns, Question of the Week and tagged , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to Question of the Week #5

  1. mende says:

    The 1864 Valley Campaign

  2. cc2001 says:

    1864–signalled the death knell of the Confederacy.

  3. sfwatson says:

    1864 because of the Burning. Demorallizing destruction of public and personal property.

  4. joe truglio says:

    I agree with all of the above. It is also ,perhaps, the single most reason why there is still animosity today.

  5. Ned B says:

    1862. Its impact on strategic and command decisions was greater.

  6. Frank J. Piatek says:

    I agree with Ned B. By October, 1864, before the Battle of Cedar Creek, the South’s chances of any type of victory were probably used up anyway. The Valley Campaign of 1862 was necessary for the continued survival of the Confederacy when it mattered most.

  7. TRJohnson says:

    The comments of Frank J. Piatek and Ned B. are well taken that the 1862 campaign had greater strategic military significance, because the valley continued to distract Federal attention and divert resources from other campaigns for the remainder of the war. But, as touched upon by Joe Truglio, the 1864 campaign may be more significant from a broader political perspective because it may have done greater harm to the process of reunification of the country than it did to contribute to the surrender of the Army of Northern Virginia. Good question!

  8. Lyle Smith says:

    1862… Lincoln hampered McClellan by not allowing McDowell to join up with him.

Please leave a comment and join the discussion!