“Now It Seems Strange To Me That We Do Not Receive The Same Pay”

An illustration of the Battle of Olustee. USCT troops are shown in the foreground.

Last weekend, I spent some time looking at primary sources addressing the pay inequality experienced by African American soldiers during the Civil War and what that represented and meant. The soldiers’ own letters provide reminders of the racism these men faced as they enlisted to fight for freedom and the concept of Union.

One soldier in the 54th Massachusetts Infantry Regiment wrote to a newspaper editor in 1864, detailing the unit’s combat experience during the Battle of Olustee. He then addressed the discrimination in pay and rations that he and his comrades faced.

MR. EDITOR: – Sir: – It is with pleasure that I now seat myself to inform you concerning our last battle: thus we were in Co. B, on the 20th of Feb. Mr. Editor, I am not sitting down to inform about this battle without knowing something about it.

The battle took place in a grove called Olustee, with the different regiments as follows: First was the 8th U.S.; they were cut up badly, and they were the first colored regiment in the battle. The next were the 54th Mass., which I belong to; the next were the 1st N.C. In they went and fired a few rounds, but they soon danced out, things were too warm for them. The firing was very warm, and it continued for about three hours and a half. The 54th was the last off the field. When the 1st N.C. found out it was so warm they soon left, and then there was none left to cover the retreat. But captain J. Walton, of the 54th, of our company, with shouts and cheers, cried, “Give it to them my brave boys! Give it to them!” As I turned around, I observed Col. E.N. Holowell standing with a smile upon his countenance, as though the boys were playing a small game of ball.

There was none left but the above named, and Lieut. Col. Hooper, and also Col. Montgomery; those were the only field officers that were left with us. If we had been like those regiments that were ahead, I think not only in my own mind, but in the minds of the field officers, such as Col. Hooper and Col. Montgomery, that we would have suffered much loss, is plain to be seen, for the enemy had taken some three of four of their pieces.

When we got there we rushed in double-quick, with a command from the General, “Right into line.” We commenced with a severe firing, and the enemy soon gave way for some two hundred yards. Our forces were light, and we were compelled to fall back with much dissatisfaction.

Now it seems strange to me that we do not receive the same pay and rations as the white soldiers. Do we not fill the same ranks? Do we not cover the same space of ground? Do we not take up the same length of ground in the grave-yard that others do? The ball does not miss the black man and strike the white, nor the white and strike the black. But, sir, at that time there is no distinction made, they strike one as much as another. The black men have to go through the same hurling of musketry, and the same belching of cannonading as white soldiers do.

It has been nearly a year since we have received any pay; but the white soldiers get their pay every two months; ($13.00 per month,) but when it comes to the poor negro he gets none. The 54th left Boston on the 28th of May, 1863. In time of enlisting members for the regiment, they were promised the same pay, and the same rations as other soldiers. Since that time the government must have charged them more for clothing than any other regiment; for those who died in a month or two after their enlistment, it was actually said that they were in debt to the government. Those who bled and died on James’ Island and Wagner, are the same. Why is it not so with other soldiers? Because our faces are black. We are put beneath the very lowest rioters of New York. We have never brought any disgrace by cowardice, on the State we left.

E.D.W.
Co. B, 54th Mass., Vol.
Jacksonville, Fla., March 13th, 1864.

Source:

I found the letter posted in a Modern American Syllabus: https://blogs.baruch.cuny.edu/his1005spring2011/2011/02/11/a-letter-from-a-member-in-54th-massachusetts-regiment/ It appears that the original is held by a separate archive.

About Sarah Kay Bierle

I’m Sarah Kay Bierle, historian, editor, and historical fiction writer. When sharing history, I try to keep the facts interesting and understandable. History is about real people, real actions, real effects and it should inspire us today.
This entry was posted in Common Soldier, Primary Sources, USCT and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

6 Responses to “Now It Seems Strange To Me That We Do Not Receive The Same Pay”

  1. John Foskett says:

    Sarah: Thanks for posting this. The new issue of Civil War Monitor has an article about the 54th and how its treatment in the newspapers became more negative along about 1864. Among the issues addressed is the matter of pay.

  2. Arthur Foley says:

    It is interesting to note that blacks serving with any of
    the Indian Brigades ,( 1st, 2nd, 3rd Indian Home Guard ),
    were paid the same as whites.

  3. Scott Hagara says:

    Thanks for this article. Just curious, could African American soldiers get any kind of enlistment bonus when they signed on? To me, the enlistment bonuses were huge when compared to the meager $13/mo pay.

  4. All ways enjoy your post Sarah . MAY BE POOR TIMING FOR THIS ONE . i M SURE SOME ONE WILL DEMAND WE MAKE UP FOR THE PAY DIFFERENCE. .

  5. David Corbett says:

    One consideration: Negroes were not citizens. Auxillary troops were not paid the same as Roman legionaires.

  6. wdonohue1 says:

    As powerfully written as was your article and the soldier’s letter I found the responses almost equally so.

Please leave a comment and join the discussion!